When rent is due Friday and payday is the following Wednesday, a payday loan can look like the only door open. It usually isn’t. Below are the options we’d look at first, roughly in order of cost, along with what a payday loan really costs so you can compare.
What a payday loan costs
The CFPB describes a payday loan as “usually a short-term, high-cost loan, generally for $500 or less, that is typically due on your next payday” (CFPB). You typically give the lender a post-dated check or permission to withdraw from your bank account.
The FTC says lenders “usually charge from $10 to $30 for every $100 borrowed,” and that a fee of $15 per $100 “translates to an annual percentage rate (APR) of 391%” (FTC).
Say someone borrows $400 for two weeks at a hypothetical $15 per $100. The fee is $60, and $460 is due on payday. If they can’t pay it all and the lender allows a rollover, the FTC notes each rollover brings a new fee, so another two weeks costs another $60, and the original $400 is still owed. Two rollovers in, they’ve paid $180 in fees without reducing the debt.
Rules differ a lot by state. The CFPB notes that some states don’t allow payday lending at all, and others cap fees.
Option 1: Ask for more time
It sounds too simple, but it’s often the cheapest fix. Call the landlord, utility, card issuer or medical provider before the due date and ask for an extension or a payment plan. The FTC lists this first among its alternatives. A late fee from a creditor who agrees to wait a week is often far less than a payday loan fee.
Many utilities run hardship programs, and dialing 211 can connect you with local help for rent, food and bills.
Option 2: A credit union payday alternative loan (PAL)
Federal credit unions can offer two types of small-dollar “payday alternative loans” under National Credit Union Administration rules (12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)). Not every credit union offers them, and you’ll need to be a member.
| PAL I | PAL II | |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $200 to $1,000 | Up to $2,000 |
| Term | 1 to 6 months | 1 to 12 months |
| Membership before borrowing | At least one month | No minimum waiting period in the rule |
| Application fee | Reasonable, never more than $20 | Reasonable, never more than $20 |
| Maximum rate | 28% | 28% |
| Repayment | Fully amortizing installments, no rollovers | Fully amortizing installments, no rollovers; no overdraft or NSF fees tied to the loan |
| Watch out for | You can’t have more than one PAL at a time or more than three in any rolling six months | Same limits apply across both types |
The 28% figure comes from the NCUA’s rule letting PALs carry a rate 1,000 basis points above the general federal credit union ceiling. In February 2026 the NCUA extended that ceiling at 18% through 2027-09-10, and said federal credit unions “may still charge up to 28 percent on payday alternative loans” (NCUA letter 26-FCU-02).
Here’s the same $400 as a hypothetical PAL II at the full 28% over three months: payments of about $139.60 a month, about $18.81 in interest, plus an application fee of up to $20. Total cost: under $40, versus $60 for a single two-week payday loan.
The rules also encourage credit unions to underwrite using proof of income, such as recent pay stubs, so bring those when you apply.
Option 3: A small loan from your bank
The FTC notes that some community banks and larger banks offer small loans or lines of credit, which it says can be up to $1,000. If you already have a checking account, look in your bank’s app or ask a branch. Terms vary, so compare the APR and fees as you would any loan.
Option 4: A credit card you already have
If you have a card with available credit, putting the bill itself on the card is usually cheaper than a payday loan, especially if you can pay it off within a month or two. A cash advance is a different matter: it usually comes with a fee and a separate, higher rate that starts right away. Your card agreement lists both.
Option 5: Paycheck advances and cash advance apps
Some employers offer pay advances, and a number of apps advance part of your upcoming paycheck. Costs come in different forms: monthly subscriptions, fees for instant transfers, and “tips” the app asks for. Even small fees add up when the advance is for a week or two. Read the fee screen before accepting, and check whether the app debits your account automatically on payday, which can trigger overdrafts if your pay is late.
Option 6: Personal and community sources
- Family or friends. The FTC lists this as an option. Writing down the amount and repayment date can protect the relationship.
- Local charities, churches and community groups. The FTC mentions these too, especially for rent, utilities and food.
- An early tax refund. If you’re owed a refund, filing electronically with direct deposit gets it to you fastest, per the FTC.
Option 7: A nonprofit credit counselor
If the shortfall is not a one-time gap but a regular one, the FTC suggests nonprofit credit counseling. A counselor can help build a budget and may suggest a debt management plan if card payments are part of the squeeze.
What about car title loans?
A car title loan is not a safer alternative. The FTC says title loans often have monthly finance fees as high as 25%, about 300% APR, typically last 15 or 30 days, and the lender “may repossess your vehicle, even if you’ve been making partial payments.” Losing the car can mean losing the way to get to work. We explain how collateral changes the stakes in secured vs unsecured loans.
After the gap: a small buffer for next time
Once this month is handled, the thing that breaks the cycle is a cushion, even a small one. You’re far from alone in not having one yet: in the Federal Reserve’s survey of households for 2025, 63% of adults said they’d cover a $400 emergency expense with cash or its equivalent, which means 37% would not.
The CFPB’s guide to building an emergency fund doesn’t set a dollar target. It suggests looking at what your most common unexpected expenses have cost in the past and using that as a goal. Its practical ideas:
- Set up a small automatic transfer to savings on payday, or split your direct deposit if your employer allows it.
- Save part of a tax refund or a cash gift to get started.
- Ask creditors whether a bill’s due date can move closer to your payday.
A few hundred dollars set aside can be the difference between a phone call and a $60 fee next time.
Your plan
- Write down the exact amount and date you need it by.
- Call the creditor first and ask for an extension or plan.
- Check your credit union (or join one you’re eligible for) and ask about PAL I or PAL II.
- Check your bank for a small-dollar loan.
- Compare the total cost of each option in dollars, not just the rate.
- If you do take a short-term loan, plan how you’ll repay it without borrowing again.
If you can wait a little longer for the money, how personal loans work explains the larger installment option, and buy now, pay later covers splitting a single purchase.
We describe options and their costs in general terms. Which one fits depends on your state, your accounts and what you can repay, and this isn’t individual financial advice.